Daily Archives: November 17, 2026

Murder by Death (1976)

By Richard Winters

My Rating: 4 out of 10

4-Word Review: Famous detectives solve murder.

Six famous detectives: Sidney Wang (Peter Sellers), Sam Diamond (Peter Falk), Milo Perrier (James Coco), Jessica Marbles (Elsa Lancaster), and Dick and Dora Charleston (David Niven, Maggie Smith) get invited to a large, isolated mansion in order to solve a mystery. They’re invited by Lionel Twain (Truman Capote) who calls himself the greatest criminologist in the world and wants to test his skill against theirs by staging a murder and seeing which ones can figure out who did it.

This is the first of Neil Simon’s two detective parodies with the later one being The Cheap Detective, This one did a bit better with audiences and critics because it wasn’t so talky and came with a lot of campy visuals to help keep the action going. However, a lot of the twists don’t make sense and seem to get thrown in for the sake of silliness with no bearing on whether it fits into the plot. The rotating room is a good example. I didn’t see how any of that helped to solve the crime or deepen the mystery. It also seems questionable that people could be in a rotating room and not feel it moving, but that’s a whole different argument.

In either case if you’re a fan of mysteries, you’ll be sorely disappointed as there’s absolutely no attempt to create a cohesive plot. In fact, if you hate the genre this may actually be appealing as it seems to just want to make fun of everything about it. Sort of like tearing it all down for the sake of a cheap laugh.

The comedy is a bit lame. I particularly disliked the humor aimed at the blind butler played by Alec Guinness that reveals no understanding at how a real blind person thinks or behaves. If a person is impaired visually then their other senses become more heightened, so if someone is standing next to them, they’ll know it because they’ll hear their breathing or feel their body heat. They’d also be able to put stamps on an envelope because they’d be able to feel the corner of it and not just stupidly stick them onto a desk like here. Same goes for carrying a bowl that has no soup in it, which they’d be able to quickly figure out because the bowl wouldn’t weigh as much and there would be no steam rising, nor any aroma and a sighted person would not be required to explain this to them.

The rest of the cast fares better. Falk virtually steals it with his crude comments and gruff demeanor. Estelle Winwood, who was already in her 90’s at the time, has a few good moments as a wheelchair bound nurse. Niven, whose health hadn’t yet declined which affected his appearances in his movies after this, is engaging as the bickering half of a married couple and Coco had me laughing during the scene when he makes all sorts of goofy faces towards the butler.

As for Capote his presence kind of works. When I originally saw the film as a child I didn’t feel his moments worked mainly because he’s not a trained actor and his delivery is just not on par with the others, reportedly Simon and director Robert Moore considered having him replaced during the production because of this, but it’s still kind of fun to see a gay man driving the action in an era when that was still not fashionable.

Spoiler Alert!

The dumb ending, which consists of Capote turning up dead at one point and then alive the next, pretty much ruins it. If he really wasn’t stabbed in the back like the viewer is made to think at one point, then these professional detectives would’ve figured that out when they examined his body These characters are portrayed as being dim-witted, but nobody could be quite that stupid. Then there’s the issue of him pulling off his mask and exposing himself as being the mute maid, played by Nancy Walker, but that’s too exaggerated to even be remotely believable and only adds more questions than answers. Like I said if all you’re looking for is a few cheap laughs here and there you’ll find it, but don’t expect anything more than that.

My Rating: 4 out of 10

Released: June 23, 1976

Runtime: 1 Hour 34 Minutes

Rated PG

Director: Robert Moore

Studio: Columbia Pictures

Available: DVD. Blu-ray, Amazon Video. YouTube