Superman (1978)

By Richard Winters

My Rating: 8 out of 10

4-Word Review: The Man of Steel.

As the planet Krypton gets set to be destroyed by its exploding sun, Jor-El (Marlon Brando) and his wife Lara (Susannah York) put their child on a spaceship that takes him to the planet earth. It is there that his spaceship crash lands into a wheat field that his spotted by Jonathan (Glenn Ford) and Martha (Phyllis Thaxter) who take the child in and treat him as their own. The boy is named Clark (Christopher Reeve) and as he grows, he begins to show amazing abilities including running faster than is humanely possible and incredible strength. Once he becomes an adult, he gets a job as a reporter at the Daily Planet newspaper where he meets fellow reporter Lois Lane (Margot Kidder). He even saves her, while dressed as a superhero, from a helicopter accident and becomes known initially as the ‘caped wonder’ before finally being coined as Superman. His publicity attracts the attention of criminal mastermind Lex Luthor (Gene Hackman) who devises a plan to steal missiles and use them to create an earthquake along the San Andreas fault and thus casting off coastal California into the ocean and turning the desert land he purchased into prime real estate. Superman attempts to stop him, but Lex has found one thing that can stop him: a meteorite known as kryptonite.

At the time this film, which suffered from numerous behind-the-scenes problems and infighting, was made it was the most expensive one ever produced with a whopping $55 million budget. While the effects were mesmerizing for many back-in-the-day I don’t know if they still all hold-up. The flying segments particularly over the Statue of Liberty is impressive to a degree but can’t quite equal today’s technology and appears like two people in front of a greenscreen as does the giant red sun that moves in to destroy Kyrpton. Watching the young Clark Kent running alongside a train looks tacky too like he’s being held up by invisible wires, which he was, and his feet aren’t really ever touching the ground. In all fairness though the earthquake segment and the destruction of the Hoover Dam and the shaking of the Golden Gate Bridge remains top notch.

The script though, which takes on quite a lot and had to be slimmed down from its original 500-page version that was written by Mario Puzo, feels rushed at times and glosses over certain things that I felt should’ve been a little more drawn-out particularly when the Kents find the boy crash land in the field. The film makes it look like they just left the remains of the spaceship in the field making me think other people in the area would’ve also come upon it later and would start a panic that some alien had come out of it and invaded the town. Later on, we come to realize that the ship got hidden inside their barn, but there’s no scene showing them transporting it, or how they went about doing that, which I felt should’ve been put in for the simple sake of clarity.

Watching Superman orbit the earth in an attempt to get it to spin backwards and supposedly ‘turn back time’ is kind of cool to see and an interesting concept though not totally plausible. Making the world rotate the other way would certainly change some things like having the sun rise in the west instead of the east and have the ocean waves go in a different direction among other things, but causing everything to essentially ‘rewind’ and go back to the way they were even bringing certain people who had died suddenly back to life just wasn’t completely convincing though it’s not enough to hurt the movie as a whole.

Most fans will likely tell me I’m quibbling about the Clark Kent disguise though when you really think about it it’s not much of a disguise at all. I admit watching this muscular guy dressed in a suit and acting all clumsy and wimpy is amusing especially the way Reeve plays it but besides combing his hair in a different direction than when he’s Superman the only other difference is that he wears glasses. However, that would be tantamount to saying someone who does wear glasses but then comes to work one day without them would not be recognized by any of his friends, or co-workers especially when he’s still speaking in the same voice making me believe that Lois and Jimmy, played by Marc McClure, should and would’ve caught on to this pretty quickly. I realize the comic book did it this way, but when it got updated into a movie, they should’ve reenvisioned it a little by adding more to the Clark get-up like besides just glasses he’d also have a mustache, or goatee and speak a bit differently, so having those close to him not catch-on would be more understandable.

I think what I enjoyed most was Hackman, who didn’t play a lot of villains during his career but is highly enjoyable here. Initially he didn’t want to take the part as he felt playing a campy character would tarnish his reputation of being a serious actor, but the change of pace does him good and proves if anything how versatile he is. His refusal not to shave his head, as the Lex Luthor in the comic is bald, works in his favor as his hair gets styled differently in each scene in order to represent him wearing a wig, which creates a creative visual. Valerie Perrine is great too as his girlfriend Miss Teschmacher who helps contrast his delusional personality with her more grounded sensibilities and I just loved the way he’d yell out her name every time he got annoyed with her, which is the comedy highlight.

The rest of the supporting cast though, made up of big name starts like Trevor Howard, Maria Schell, and even Larry Hagman didn’t seem needed and given such few lines I was surprised why they’d even take the roles unless it was because of the money. Brando is an equal waste. He’s given top billing and paid an exorbitant amount of money including a percentage of the profits despite refusing to memorize his dialogue and even having his lines written on the baby’s diaper for him to read off of as he puts the child into the spaceship. Had the producers skipped the unimportant ‘star power’ and cast lesser knowns in these roles they could’ve saved themselves a lot of money, which in retrospect might’ve lessened the tensions they had with director Richard Donner for going over budget and ultimately lead to his firing and a very tumultuous follow-up Superman II, which will be covered in the next review.

My Rating: 8 out of 10

Released: December 10, 1978

Runtime: 1 Hour 23 Minutes

Rated PG

Director: Richard Donner

Studio: Warner Brothers

Available: DVD, Blu-ray, Amazon Video, YouTube

9 responses to “Superman (1978)

  1. At a time when superhero movies could feel most especially original, 1978’s Superman is one I always have great fondness for. The issues with big name casting like Marlon Brando, Gene Hackman and Ned Beatty’s comic relief as Otis may have been inevitable to some degree. Personally I admire how more sophisticated the casting for superhero movies has become in recent years, given the surprising success of Heath Ledger as the Joker, Colin Farrell as the Penguin and Aaron Eckhart as Two Face. But for the role of the superhero, I’ll always be grateful for the unmatched-to-this-day impression that Christopher Reeve originally made on me. Hackman is always quite nicely memorable as Lex Luthor, even with the quite profound change to the villain that Michael Cudlitz made in Superman & Lois which I also admire. As much as I appreciate how far this superhero legacy has come and how far it can still go, it’s comforting to know that we will always have 1978’s Superman. Thank you for your review.

  2. You’re being awfully nit-picky about a number of things. How the Kent’s got the ship from the field to their barn is irrelevant to the narrative. Actors like Larry Hagman with so few lines weren’t motivated by money, they were motivated for the chance to basically make a cameo in a first of it’s kind movie, and have some fun. (Much in the same way Gene Hackman makes an uncredited appearance in “Young Frankenstein” and he was brilliant!) Brando got what he wanted because the Salkinds needed a marquee star to give the project credibility. If Brando’s name wasn’t attached to the project, Gene Hackman wouldn’t have given the script a second look. It’s still the best of all the “Superman” films, one of the best movies you’ll ever see. The effects didn’t all age very well. But at the end of the movie, it leaves you feeling really good. Name another picture that accomplishes that.

    • One point you’re saying actors got involved in order to be in ‘a first of its kind movie’ and then the next you’re saying they only did it because Brando was involved, so which is it? There’s no indication anywhere that I’ve read that Hackman got onboard because of Brando, nor has he ever mentioned it in any interview I’ve seen.

      Hagman was doing a lot of small roles in low budget and obscure foreign films at the time to stay busy as his career was at a nadir before getting the ‘Dallas’ role, so I’m pretty sure he did this one like those for the pay.

      Not showing how the Kent’s got the ship from the field to the farmhouse still leaves open a lot of questions like why didn’t the other townspeople not notice the black burn scar left on the field when the ship landed, or how was that covered up?

      • The Kents took on quite a responsibility with being the adoptive parents to a boy from space. So any need for a cover-up, whatever form it would have to take, may say a lot about how humans respond to such extraordinary things. We know that Kryptonite as Lex Luthor was able to find was recovered somehow. The freedom of our imagination to fill in the gaps is of course appreciable. Especially when it can be a lot more fun.

  3. Thanks for the review. Just got the Blu for Christmas.

  4. Sad news. Gene Hackman has passed away.

    • From Popeye Doyle to Lex Luthor and beyond, Gene will be among the most greatly remembered and greatly missed. My favorite movie performance by Gene was in The Chamber. I remember rumors that he was set to do a second sequel to The French Connection in the 90s. Somehow that didn’t happen but it would have been interesting. R.I.P., Gene.

      • Yes, such a wonderful actor. Ironically I was just thinking about watching my ‘The Chamber’ DVD.

      • It’s so hard for me to pick a favorite Gene Hackman performance because he was so good in all of them, but outside of Lex Luthor I really did like him in ‘The Conversation’.

Leave a reply to scifimike70 Cancel reply